Dr Alan Cusack (Associate Professor of Law, University of Limerick) As the primary gatekeepers of Ireland’s criminal justice system, members of An Garda Síochána enjoy unparalleled influence over the trajectory of a criminal investigation (Cusack, 2018). Moreover, as first responders to alleged acts of criminality they are uniquely placed to identify and deploy essential pre-trial,Continue reading “Protecting Vulnerable Suspects: A Survey of Existing and Emerging Pre-Trial Safeguards in Ireland”
Author Archives: sfairclough1
How many defendants self-represent and has there been a change in the number of defendants self-representing in recent years?
Dr Charlotte Walker (Lecturer in Social Sciences, York St John University) Introduction This blog post discusses some findings from my own research study, which examined unrepresented defendants and their experience at court. Attention in this post will specifically be on the number of defendants self-representing in the magistrates’ court and whether there has been anContinue reading “How many defendants self-represent and has there been a change in the number of defendants self-representing in recent years?”
Identifying the vulnerable detainee in an English Police custody suite: Do Criminal Justice Liaison and Diversion (CJLD) practitioners share the view of police custody staff?
Dr Jo Wells (Lecturer in Criminology, Bournemouth University) Introduction National Health Service England (NHSE) oversees a national network of CJLD schemes who adapt a generic service specification to identify justice-involved individuals meeting the threshold for intervention under their all-vulnerability criteria(NHS England 2019) . The model of delivery embeds CJLD teams in county police force custodyContinue reading “Identifying the vulnerable detainee in an English Police custody suite: Do Criminal Justice Liaison and Diversion (CJLD) practitioners share the view of police custody staff?”
The early identification of suspect vulnerability: the added value and limitations of existing tools and the potential of a new toolkit.
Prof. dr. Lore Mergaerts (Leuven Institute of Criminology, KU Leuven) Introduction Over the last decade, the procedural rights of suspects during the pre-trial investigation – and police questioning in particular – have been increasingly emphasized. In this regard, the increased attention given to the exercise of procedural rights by so-called vulnerable suspects at both EuropeanContinue reading “The early identification of suspect vulnerability: the added value and limitations of existing tools and the potential of a new toolkit.”
“One’s credibility is a core feature of one’s identity” (William Hirstein, 2009): Considering Confabulation, Confession, Credibility and the Criminal Justice System.
Michelle White (Teeside University) Introduction With the rapid growth in popularity of Netflix-esque crime documentaries and the notoriety afforded to contemporary appeals cases, both domestically(e.g. R v Kiszko) and internationally(e.g. West Memphis 3, Innocence Project 2023), the perplexing quality of false confessions has never before occupied such a prominent place in the public’s awareness. However,Continue reading ““One’s credibility is a core feature of one’s identity” (William Hirstein, 2009): Considering Confabulation, Confession, Credibility and the Criminal Justice System.”
The Silence of Neurodivergence in the Youth Justice System
Dr Anne-Marie Day (Manchester Metropolitan University) Introduction Neurodivergent children are over-represented in the youth justice system in England and Wales, and experience a range of harms that isolate, exclude and stigmatise them. But very little attention has been given to their experiences in the youth justice system. This is despite the fact that up toContinue reading “The Silence of Neurodivergence in the Youth Justice System”
Speech, language and communication needs – what support is required for defendants?
Kim Turner, Speech and Language Therapist and Senior Lecturer, Department of Health Professions, Manchester Metropolitan University. Claire Westwood, Speech and Language Therapist and Lecturer, School of Health and Care Professions, Birmingham City University. Introduction Imagine sitting through an entire trial where you don’t understand any of the charges or evidence against you. Questions are repeatedlyContinue reading “Speech, language and communication needs – what support is required for defendants?”
Anonymity for Persons Accused of Sexual Offences in Northern Ireland: Addressing Post-Acquittal Stigma, Shame, and Vulnerability
Chloe Hanna, PhD researcher (Queen’s University, Belfast) This paper will explore the post-acquittal vulnerability of persons accused of serious sexual offences in Northern Ireland. Drawing on qualitative interviews, it proposes an extension of defendant anonymity until the point of conviction as a means to address the stigma and shame experienced by accused individuals in theContinue reading “Anonymity for Persons Accused of Sexual Offences in Northern Ireland: Addressing Post-Acquittal Stigma, Shame, and Vulnerability”
“Missing the signs”: An legal-ethical analysis of ‘good’ lawyering for the neurodivergent accused
Dr Tom Smith, Associate Professor in Law, UWE Bristol Introduction Good lawyering is fundamental to the protection of vulnerable individuals accused of criminal offences – but causes one to question what ‘good’ lawyering is in this context. One method of assessing this would be consideration of how effectively lawyers discharge their professional duties for such clients.Continue reading ““Missing the signs”: An legal-ethical analysis of ‘good’ lawyering for the neurodivergent accused”
Vulnerable defendants: Longstanding Challenges and Overdue Research
Professor Penny Cooper (ICPR, Birkbeck, University of London) Introduction Effective participation in the courtroom is the right of every defendant. Vulnerable defendants are entitled to adjustments to support their effective participation. These two sentences are uncontroversial enough, but the reality of their implementation in the courtroom is not. The meaning of ‘effective participation’, who canContinue reading “Vulnerable defendants: Longstanding Challenges and Overdue Research”